Back to list

Employee unfairly dismissed due to lack of proper redundancy consultation

It’s a word no one particularly likes to hear – redundancy. Nevertheless, it actually serves an important purpose. When it comes to a redundancy situation, companies can’t just make dismiss an employee on a whim – there are strict rules that they have to follow as part of the redundancy process.

 

A key aspect of this is the consultation period, which varies largely based on the reasons for redundancy and the size of the company. It is the consultation period aspect of redundancy which we will be looking at in more detail today.

 

High profiles events such as Elon Musk’s takeover of Twitter reminds us of the need for rigorous and thorough redundancy procedure. Following Musk’s takeover of Twitter, news quickly broke that employees had been sacked overnight without the proper consultation period in the UK. The same has also happened in the US, which has prompted legal action.

 

In today’s case, we take a look at a redundancy dispute between a nurse, Ms Mogane, and Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. The significance of this case is that the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) held that in a redundancy situation, consultation of employees concerned will have to be meaningful and genuine.

 

Keep reading to learn more about redundancy consultation and why the employer fell foul of the rules in this case.

 

What is redundancy?

 

Redundancy is often a fair statutory reason for dismissal. Employees dismissed by reason of redundancy usually have the rights to:

  • A statutory redundancy payment
  • The application of a fair redundancy procedure
  • Reasonable time off work to look for alternative employment or arrange training

 

A previous case, Williams vs Compare Maxam, outlines the elements which are required for a fair dismissal procedure in a collective redundancy situation. These elements include the following:

 

  • Warning
  • Consultation
  • Objective selection criteria
  • Fair application of selection criteria
  • Consideration of alternative employment

 

Failure to follow this procedure in a collective redundancy situation will most likely render the dismissal unfair.

 

Background of the case

 

The claimant in this case was one of two band 6 nurses employed on fixed-term contracts by the respondent. While the claimant had been employed since 2016 on a series of one-year fixed term contracts, the other nurse was employed on a two year fixed-term contract. The claimant’s fixed-term contract was due for renewal prior to the renewal of the second nurse’s fixed-term contract.  The decision of which of the two nurses to make redundant represented the selection criteria process.

 

The redundancy situation was precipitated by a change in financial circumstances at the respondent’s research unit. This required a reduction in staff numbers by the Trust. The claimant was subsequently told of the financial position the respondent was facing in a meeting. Shortly afterwards, it was decided that as the claimant’s contract was due to be renewed soonest, she should be the one who should be made redundant.

 

This was challenged by the respondent’s internal HR function without success. For the remainder of the process, there was an unsuccessful attempt to find the claimant suitable alternative employment.

 

Following the conclusion of this process, the claimant was dismissed and later brought proceedings for unfair dismissal in an employment tribunal.

 

Decision of the employment tribunal

 

The employment tribunal dismissed this claim.

 

Their reasoning for this was that in a situation where all relevant employees are on short-term contracts, it is within the band of reasonable responses to base a decision on which of the employees is due for renewal at the point where there are perceived economical difficulties. It was also deemed that it is acceptable in a situation where there is a reduction in the requirement for employees in the relevant position.

 

The claimant did not accept this outcome. Ms Mogan subsequently appealed to the Employment Appeal Tribunal on the following grounds:

  • The issue of consultation in a redundancy process
  • The issue of the correct pool for selection
  • The criteria for selection
  • That the use of one criterion for selection was not one that could be considered as properly within the bounds of reasonable responses
  • That the reasons for the Tribunal’s decisions were not Meek-compliant and did not provide adequate information

 

Employment Appeal Tribunal decision

 

 

The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the appeal on the grounds that there had not been proper consultation. As briefly touched upon earlier, for a redundancy consultation to be deemed genuine and meaningful, it must take place at a stage where the employee is still able to influence the outcome.

 

The Tribunal decided that consultation should have taken place prior to the adoption of the selection criteria. This is because the choice of criteria which was chosen to select for redundancy essentially determined who would be made redundant.

 

The EAT therefore found that the claimant, Ms Mogane, was unfairly dismissed.

 

 

Our thoughts

 

This decision by the Employment Appeal Tribunal is an important reminder of the need to provide consultation with staff before the redundancy selection criteria is confirmed. It also provides useful guidance on the application of redundancy selection more generally.

 

In a redundancy situation, employers should consult with relevant employees on the selection criteria. If they do not do this, then the redundancy is likely to be hold as unlawful. While employers may want to formulate a selection criteria prior to communicating with the affected employees in order to maintain stability, it is important to be transparent about this processed, as this case demonstrates.

 

If you have enjoyed this article and would like more information, contact us using the methods below!

 

Have questions about this article? Get in touch today!

 

Call us on 020 7928 0276, our phone lines are open and we will be taking calls from 9:30am to 6:00pm.

 

Email us on info@lisaslaw.co.uk.

 

Use the Ask Lisa function on our website. Simply enter your details and leave a message, we will get right back to you: https://lisaslaw.co.uk/ask-question/

 

Or, download our free app! You can launch an enquiry, scan over documents, check progress on your case and much more!

 

Join the Conversation

280 Comments

  3. buying prescription drugs in mexico online [url=https://foruspharma.com/#]buying prescription drugs in mexico online[/url] pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa

  5. mexican drugstore online [url=http://foruspharma.com/#]medication from mexico pharmacy[/url] mexican mail order pharmacies

  6. www canadianonlinepharmacy [url=https://canadapharmast.com/#]canadian online pharmacy reviews[/url] vipps canadian pharmacy

  8. mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs [url=https://foruspharma.com/#]buying from online mexican pharmacy[/url] buying prescription drugs in mexico online

  22. mexican rx online [url=http://mexicandeliverypharma.com/#]buying prescription drugs in mexico online[/url] mexico pharmacies prescription drugs

  26. mexico pharmacies prescription drugs [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.online/#]mexican rx online[/url] buying prescription drugs in mexico online

  28. pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.online/#]medication from mexico pharmacy[/url] medicine in mexico pharmacies

  31. mexican pharmaceuticals online [url=http://mexicandeliverypharma.com/#]mexican pharmacy[/url] mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa

  36. medication from mexico pharmacy [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.online/#]mexico drug stores pharmacies[/url] buying from online mexican pharmacy

  37. mexican mail order pharmacies [url=http://mexicandeliverypharma.com/#]mexico drug stores pharmacies[/url] mexican pharmaceuticals online

  41. medication from mexico pharmacy [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.online/#]mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs[/url] pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa

  44. mexican mail order pharmacies [url=http://mexicandeliverypharma.com/#]best online pharmacies in mexico[/url] buying prescription drugs in mexico online

  50. medicine in mexico pharmacies [url=http://mexicandeliverypharma.com/#]pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa[/url] mexican mail order pharmacies

  54. buying prescription drugs in mexico online [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.com/#]п»їbest mexican online pharmacies[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies

  57. mexico pharmacies prescription drugs [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.online/#]п»їbest mexican online pharmacies[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies

  60. п»їbest mexican online pharmacies [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.online/#]mexico pharmacies prescription drugs[/url] mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  64. purple pharmacy mexico price list [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.com/#]mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa[/url] reputable mexican pharmacies online

  68. mexican pharmacy [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.online/#]medicine in mexico pharmacies[/url] mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa

  72. mexico drug stores pharmacies [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.com/#]mexican pharmaceuticals online[/url] mexican rx online

  78. mexican pharmacy [url=http://mexicandeliverypharma.com/#]mexican pharmacy[/url] mexico pharmacies prescription drugs

  83. can i order prednisone [url=https://prednisonebestprice.pro/#]prednisone drug costs[/url] buy prednisone online without a script

  85. cost of generic propecia for sale [url=https://propeciabestprice.pro/#]get generic propecia[/url] order propecia

  89. where can i order prednisone 20mg [url=http://prednisonebestprice.pro/#]how to get prednisone tablets[/url] generic over the counter prednisone

  93. prednisone 4mg tab [url=http://prednisonebestprice.pro/#]prednisone uk price[/url] prednisone over the counter

  159. lipitor price drop [url=https://lipitor.guru/#]buy atorvastatin online[/url] cheap lipitor online

  175. lipitor purchase [url=http://lipitor.guru/#]Atorvastatin 20 mg buy online[/url] lipitor generic

  192. Pingback: My Homepage

  201. mexico pharmacies prescription drugs [url=http://mexstarpharma.com/#]best online pharmacies in mexico[/url] mexico pharmacies prescription drugs

  227. pin up казино [url=http://pin-up.diy/#]пин ап казино вход[/url] пинап казино

  257. best online pharmacies in mexico [url=https://mexicopharmacy.cheap/#]mexican mail order pharmacies[/url] mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  261. top online pharmacy india [url=http://indianpharmacy.company/#]buy medicines online in india[/url] world pharmacy india

  264. pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa [url=https://mexicopharmacy.cheap/#]mexico drug stores pharmacies[/url] purple pharmacy mexico price list

  268. best online pharmacy without prescription [url=https://pharmbig24.online/#]national pharmacies online[/url] warfarin testing pharmacy

  272. cialis online uk pharmacy [url=https://pharmbig24.com/#]no prescription required pharmacy[/url] Prometrium

  274. best online pharmacies in mexico [url=https://mexicopharmacy.cheap/#]mexican pharmaceuticals online[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies

  278. indianpharmacy com [url=https://indianpharmacy.company/#]indianpharmacy com[/url] cheapest online pharmacy india

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Enquire Now
Recent Posts