At Lisa’s Law, we take pride in guiding our clients through complex legal disputes and helping them to achieve successful outcomes. Recently, we represented “Prime Talent Career Co. (PTCO)”, an international employment agency, in a company name dispute against Elite Employment Services Ltd, trading as “Prime Talent Career Placement (PTCP)“. Our client had just expanded their international business to London a year or so ago and was soon faced with threat of lawsuits.
[The names and business nature of these companies are altered and are for illustrative purposes only]
Company Names and Trading Names: The Risk of Confusion
Company name disputes occur when two businesses use similar names, potentially causing confusion to customers. These disputes often involve claims of “passing off”, where one business misrepresents its goods or services as being associated with another, damaging the established business’s reputation and goodwill.
A particular issue in these cases is the use of trading name—the names businesses use publicly, which may differ from their registered company names. Trading names can build significant goodwill and brand recognition over time, even if they are not officially registered or visible in standard company name searches. This can create unexpected conflicts, as a business might operate under one or more trading names that are not immediately visible during company formation checks.
In our case, PTCO was unaware of PTCP’s trading name when it registered its company. The similar names did not appear in the initial checks because the trading name was not listed in public registries. As a new entrant from overseas, our client had no knowledge of PTCP’s brand name, which was said to have been in use for two decades.
The Consequences of Passing Off
If a court finds that a company is passing off as another, the infringing company could potentially face severe consequences, including being forced to stop using the name, pay damages, and cover legal costs. These penalties can significantly disrupt a business’s operations and finances. PTCP sought to impose these exact outcomes on our client, demanding not only a change in name, but also substantial damages calculated from their potential sales, handing over of all marketing material, and to compensate PTCP’s legal fees.
Our Defence (Against Passing Off Claims and Unreasonable Demands)
Upon receiving the claims, our team at Lisa’s Law quickly assessed the situation. We found that the two companies did not have significant overlap. Our client primarily served international clients from Asia, offering specialised employment placement services in technology and finance sectors, which differed greatly from PTCP’s traditional, local UK placements. This distinction minimised any potential harm to PTCP and should reduce our client’s potentially exposure to liability.
Nevertheless, to avoid drawn-out legal battles, we advised our client to make reasonable changes to further differentiate their brand, including modifying the company name to “Prime Talent (UK) Career Ltd.” This step aimed to resolve any potential confusion without disrupting our client’s operations.
Despite these proactive adjustments, PTCP continued to demand that our client take further measures, including a complete abandonment of the new name, and again demanding the payment of damages and legal costs. We found these demands excessive, especially given the generic nature of the term “Prime,” the market differences, and our client’s proactive modifications.
Standing Firm Against Unreasonable Pressure
We stood firm against PTCP’s excessive demands, arguing that the names were not exclusive and that our client’s distinct business model posed no real threat of confusion or harm. Our strategy emphasized the absence of any substantial evidence showing public confusion and underscored the disproportionate nature of PTCP’s legal and financial claims.
Ultimately, our client was able to continue operating under its revised name without making further concessions or incurring any financial penalties. This outcome not only safeguarded our client’s business integrity but also demonstrated the importance of defending your rights against unjustified and excessive claims.
At Lisa’s Law, we are here to guide you through the complexities of brand protection and legal disputes. Whether you are expanding your business or defending your brand, our experienced team is dedicated to securing the best outcomes for you.
Have questions? Get in touch today!
Call us on 020 7928 0276, phone calls are operating as usual and we will be taking calls from 9:30am to 6:00pm.
Email us on info@lisaslaw.co.uk.
Use the Ask Lisa function on our website. Simply enter your details and leave a message, we will get right back to you: https://lisaslaw.co.uk/ask-question/
For more updates, follow us on our social media platforms! You can find them all on our Linktree right here.
