We recently represented a leaseholder who was facing possession proceedings and potential lease forfeiture after being unable to pay a substantial contribution towards repairs to his building. The circumstances below have been changed to preserve confidentiality, but the legal issues are based on a matter handled by Lisa’s Law.
The freeholder had obtained a County Court judgment for the outstanding sum and subsequently instructed solicitors to pursue forfeiture of the lease. Our client was understandably overwhelmed. He accepted that he owed the money and believed that, with a judgment already entered against him, there was little he could do to resist losing his flat.

Written by Paul Cheuk, Solicitor
The managing agent had agreed to instalments
While the freeholder’s solicitors were pursuing forfeiture, its managing agent continued issuing routine payment demands, including the outstanding repair contribution. Our client explained that he could not pay the entire amount immediately and proposed monthly instalments. The managing agent acknowledged the arrangement, and payments began.
Neither side appeared to appreciate the significance of this exchange. The managing agent seemingly did not know that forfeiture proceedings were being pursued, while our client regarded the payment arrangement and possession proceedings as two separate matters. Yet the freeholder was seeking possession for a debt which its own managing agent had subsequently agreed could be paid gradually.
Had the freeholder undermined its own case?
Under English law, a freeholder may waive the right to forfeit a lease if, knowing of a breach, it subsequently acts in a manner which unequivocally recognises the lease as continuing. Demanding or accepting rent becoming due after the breach is a common example, although the position concerning repair contributions depends on the lease terms and circumstances.
Separately, an instalment arrangement agreed through an authorised managing agent may affect whether the entire outstanding balance remains immediately payable. The judgment did not resolve what happened afterwards. Our client might still owe the money, but the freeholder’s right to pursue possession was a different question.
What neither side had realised
Our client already possessed the relevant emails and payment records, but had not appreciated their significance. Overwhelmed by the possession proceedings, he had simply assumed that the judgment left him with little room to defend the claim.
Meanwhile, the freeholder’s solicitors appeared to be pursuing forfeiture without knowing that its managing agent had agreed to accept instalments. This illustrates a risk for parties who continue dealing with a dispute independently after instructing solicitors. An apparently routine agreement or communication may inadvertently prejudice their own legal position, particularly where the solicitors are unaware of it.
At Lisa’s Law, we examine the full circumstances of a dispute, not simply the allegations made in court proceedings. In this matter, the difficulty with the freeholder’s case only became apparent when the correspondence was examined alongside the legal proceedings. What neither party initially regarded as important turned out to be central to the dispute.
Need legal advice? We’re here to help.
If you have questions about your situation or need advice on your next steps, our experienced legal team can help.
Call us on 020 7928 0276 between 9:30am and 6:00pm, or email [email protected].
You can also contact us online by completing our short enquiry form. Tell us a little about your situation and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible.
Not sure which service you need? Get in touch and we’ll help you identify the right team.