Back to list

Is Covid a viable defence by commercial tenants for rent arrears? No, says the Court of Appeal!

The Court of Appeal has recently found that a tenant cannot use Covid as a defence for rent arrears. The case acts as an important case study for rent arrears accrued during the pandemic as well as dispute resolution between commercial landlords and tenants.

 

The cases in question were as follows, Bank of New York Mellon (International) Limited v Cine-UK Limited and London Trocadero (2015) LLP v Picturehouse Cinemas Limited & ors. These appeals were made in the Court of Appeal by the cinema operators to quash the summary judgment in the first hearing that entitled the landlords to all rent arrears payments.

 

Keep reading to learn more about the case.

Background

 

As we all know, the lockdowns precipitated by the Covid-19 pandemic had a disastrous impact on economies across the world, affecting businesses and individuals alike. One of the types of business perhaps most affected by the pandemic were cinemas – with the activity of sitting in a room of people for hours lending itself particularly well to a virus which spreads extremely well in poorly ventilated areas.

 

The lockdowns which subsequently came in and justifiably meant that cinemas were not allowed to legally operate resulted in a considerable decrease in revenue which ran concurrently with the reality that cinemas had to continue to pay rent to their landlords. This is the topic of contention in this jointly held case.

 

Businesses from other industries have also attempted to use the pandemic as reason to avoid paying rent that was due during the pandemic, with the property fund manager First Property Group recently winning half a million pounds in rent arrears from the operators of jewellers H. Samuel and Ernest Jones.

 

The government acted on the considerable level of dispute over rent arrears which accrued during the pandemic by passing the Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Act 2022. This made provision for the enabling of rent debt relief in certain circumstances where business tenancies were adversely affected by coronavirus. This was to be made possible through arbitration.

 

The landlords in the respective cases were Bank of New York Mellon, which operates a cinema complex situated in a shopping centre in Bristol (Cine-UK), and London Trocadero, which operates a cinema complex in Piccadilly, London(Picturehouse).

 

The case

 

The tenants, Cine-UK and Picturehouse Cinemas, which are both part of the Cineworld Group, filed their appeals in late 2021, after they had been allowed to open following the end of restrictions on cinemas.

 

Cine-UK’s premises were only open for business for a very short window between March 2020 and May 2021, when they finally opened again for good. However, it wasn’t until July 2021 that cinemas were finally able to reopen unrestricted. This was also the case for the Picturehouse cinema, which was only open for about 2 months between March 2020 and May 2021.

 

Both tenants objected to the payment of rent during this period for two main reasons. Their arguments for this were as follows:

 

  • The Government restrictions imposed due to the pandemic had given them the right to seek relief from their obligation to pay rent during this period
  • It was an implied term of the agreement that should the tenant not be able to lawfully use their premises as a cinema, then they should be relieved of their obligation to pay rent.

 

Cine-UK made a third argument in the case of Bank of New York vs Cine-UK. They claimed that the phrase ‘damage or destruction’ was pertaining to non-physical damage in the form of the effect which the Covid pandemic had on the business, rather than purely physical damage or destruction.

 

Judgements

 

All of the arguments made by the tenants were rejected by the Court of Appeal.

 

With the first argument, which focused on failure of basis, the judge observed that it was “difficult to argue that the landlord had been unjustly enriched in circumstances where the rent had not been paid”.

 

The second argument, concerning implied terms of the agreement, was dismissed by the Court as the ‘leases worked well without the need for implied terms to be read into them’.

 

For the other argument which was made by Cine-UK, the judge ruled that the landlord’s argument that “damage and destruction” was limited to physical damage and destruction was correct. Cine-UK had attempted to construe the term “damage and destruction” as not being solely physical, meaning that the enforced lockdowns could come under this description as well.

 

Our thoughts

 

While these businesses clearly struggled during the pandemic as a result of not being able to open and legally operate, this was also the case for businesses up and down the country, many of which were much smaller in size than Cine-UK and Picturehouse.

 

The outcome of this case will bring much more certainty to commercial landlords, as it confirms their right to enforce against long-standing rent arrears which are not subject to mandatory arbitration. As a result, making an exception for these businesses does not seem justified, and the decision made by the judge in the Court of Appeal therefore seems to be the right one.

 

It may subsequently result in commercial tenants favouring the arbitration route in future, for which they have until 23rd September 2022 when the scheme closes.

 

Have questions about this article? Get in touch today!

 

Call us on 020 7928 0276, our phone lines are open and we will be taking calls from 9:30am to 6:00pm.

 

Email us on info@lisaslaw.co.uk.

 

Use the Ask Lisa function on our website. Simply enter your details and leave a message, we will get right back to you: https://lisaslaw.co.uk/ask-question/

 

Or, download our free app! You can launch an enquiry, scan over documents, check progress on your case and much more!

 

Join the Conversation

242 Comments

  1. Prijs van symmetrel in Gent, België prijs van symmetrel in Amsterdam
    symmetrel bestellen in Nederland: Veilig en discreet
    symmetrel zonder voorschrift in Bolivia online aankoop
    van amantadine zonder recept
    Ontvang amantadine snel en eenvoudig bij u thuis in Nederland
    symmetrel bestellen zonder recept: snel en discreet
    symmetrel verkrijgbaar in Zwitserland Online amantadine kopen in Nederland
    amantadine kopen in Nederlandse apotheek symmetrel te koop in Europa
    Aankoop van amantadine online in Brugge, België
    bestel amantadine in Brussel
    symmetrel zonder recept in Zwitserland amantadine
    online bestellen zonder voorschrift in Nederland
    kopen van symmetrel in Spanje
    amantadine te koop in België zonder voorschrift symmetrel zonder voorschrift veilig
    online bestellen
    amantadine zonder recept online aanschaffen
    informeer naar de prijs van symmetrel met medisch voorschrift in Nederland
    symmetrel kopen zonder recept: snel en gemakkelijk amantadine prijsvergelijking online
    vrij verkrijgbare symmetrel in België Online kopen amantadine
    voor snelle verzending in Nederland
    symmetrel prijs in Zwitserland symmetrel zonder recept verkrijgbaar in Zwitserland
    online aankoop van amantadine
    amantadine zonder recept bestellen online
    symmetrel online bestellen: betrouwbaarheid en gemak in Nederland.
    Voordelig symmetrel kopen zonder recept in Nederland.

    Koop amantadine online in Amsterdam Beste deals
    voor symmetrel in Nederland
    amantadine beschikbaar op voorschrift symmetrel online kopen zonder doktersvoorschrift vereist
    Bestel amantadine online en vermijd lange wachtrijen in de apotheek
    amantadine te bestellen zonder voorschrift
    Raadpleeg een arts voor een recept van symmetrel in Haarlem, Nederland amantadine kopen zonder gedoe
    bij online apotheken in Nederland.
    amantadine op recept prijs in Rotterdam symmetrel bestellen: Snelle levering in Nederland
    symmetrel online bestellen met snelle verzending Goedkope amantadine zonder
    recept verkrijgbaar
    kopen symmetrel in Duitsland
    symmetrel kopen zonder voorschrift nodig te hebben symmetrel kopen België
    Bestel symmetrel zonder voorschrift voor directe verlichting symmetrel online kopen in Nederland
    symmetrel kopen zonder recept: snel en gemakkelijk

  9. india online pharmacy [url=https://indiapharmast.com/#]pharmacy website india[/url] india pharmacy

  11. top 10 online pharmacy in india [url=http://indiapharmast.com/#]reputable indian pharmacies[/url] Online medicine home delivery

  27. mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs [url=http://mexicandeliverypharma.com/#]mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs[/url] mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa

  37. mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.online/#]mexican pharmacy[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies

  44. purple pharmacy mexico price list [url=http://mexicandeliverypharma.com/#]pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa[/url] mexican rx online

  52. mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.com/#]pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa[/url] mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  56. mexico pharmacy [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.online/#]mexican pharmacy[/url] п»їbest mexican online pharmacies

  60. mexican rx online [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.online/#]mexico pharmacy[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies

  75. mexican drugstore online [url=https://mexicandeliverypharma.online/#]mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa[/url] pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa

  78. order cytotec online [url=https://cytotecbestprice.pro/#]buy cytotec[/url] buy cytotec pills online cheap

  81. buy generic zithromax online [url=https://zithromaxbestprice.pro/#]buy zithromax canada[/url] zithromax z-pak

  85. prednisone 20 mg generic [url=http://prednisonebestprice.pro/#]prednisone cost us[/url] prednisone online sale

  89. aromatase inhibitor tamoxifen [url=http://nolvadexbestprice.pro/#]is nolvadex legal[/url] tamoxifen rash

  153. Misoprostol 200 mg buy online [url=https://cytotec.pro/#]buy cytotec online[/url] buy cytotec over the counter

  159. lisinopril 5 mg canada [url=http://lisinopril.guru/#]generic drug for lisinopril[/url] lisinopril 422

  178. mexico pharmacies prescription drugs [url=https://mexstarpharma.com/#]medication from mexico pharmacy[/url] buying from online mexican pharmacy

  181. indian pharmacy paypal [url=https://easyrxindia.com/#]indian pharmacies safe[/url] Online medicine home delivery

  185. canadian pharmacy meds reviews [url=https://easyrxcanada.online/#]ed drugs online from canada[/url] canadadrugpharmacy com

  223. vibration analysis
    The Value of Oscillation Regulation Systems in Mechanical Systems
    In manufacturing settings, devices and spinning machinery act as the core of manufacturing. Yet, one of the highly widespread problems that might hinder the operation as well as lifetime exists as resonance. Vibrations might cause a series of complications, including reduced perfection and performance leading to heightened erosion, eventually resulting in costly interruptions as well as fixes. This scenario is where vibration regulation systems becomes essential.

    Why Vibration Management remains Critical

    Vibration in equipment can cause various adverse effects:

    Decreased Production Efficiency: Excess vibrations may result in misalignments and unbalance, reducing overall efficiency of the devices. Such might cause slower production times as well as higher energy use.

    Greater Wear and Tear: Ongoing oscillation speeds up overall erosion in machinery parts, bringing about increased servicing along with the chance of unexpected unforeseen malfunctions. Such a scenario not only increases operational costs as well as limits the longevity of the existing machinery.

    Safety Risks: Excessive resonance may bring substantial dangers to the machinery and the machines along with the operators. In severe cases, serious conditions, this might bring about catastrophic equipment breakdown, endangering workers along with causing extensive harm to the site.

    Accuracy and Production Quality Problems: Within industries that require high precision, such as manufacturing and aviation, resonance could lead to discrepancies in production, producing defective products and more waste.

    Reasonably Priced Solutions for Oscillation Control

    Investing in resonance control equipment is not merely a necessity and a smart decision for any organization that relies on mechanical systems. The offered modern vibration mitigation tools work to intended to remove vibrations within various machinery or rotational systems, ensuring smooth and efficient functioning.

    What sets our tools apart is its cost-effectiveness. We know the importance of affordability in today’s competitive market, which is why we have top-tier vibration management solutions at rates that remain budget-friendly.

    By choosing our equipment, you’re not only preserving your equipment along with improving its operational effectiveness but also investing towards the long-term success of your business.

    Final Thoughts

    Vibration management is an essential aspect in preserving the operational performance, security, and durability of your machinery. Through our cost-effective vibration control equipment, you can ensure that your operations operate seamlessly, your products maintain high quality, and your workers remain safe. Do not permit vibrations undermine your operations—invest in the appropriate systems now.

  224. Internet gambling sites deliver an exhilarating range of casino games, many of these currently incorporate cryptocurrency as a method of payment. Among the leading casinos, BC Casino, Fortune Panda, Axe Casino, and Kingz Casino are growing in popularity, whereas Bitstarz Casino stands out with multiple recognitions. Cloudbet Casino is known for operating as a licensed crypto casino, providing security for players and fair play, meanwhile Fairspin and Mbit Casino offer a broad selection of crypto-friendly games.

    For dice games, digital currency casinos such as BTC Dice bring an exciting gambling experience, allowing bettors to wager in Bitcoin and other digital currencies like Ethereum, Litecoin, Dogecoin, BNB, and Tether USD.

    For casino enthusiasts, deciding on the right provider is crucial. Thunderkick Casino, Play’n Go, Red Tiger Casino, Quick Spin, Pragmatic Play, Playtech, Nolimit City Gaming, NetEnt Casino, ELK Studios, and Microgaming Casino are known as the top game developers renowned for their innovative slot machines, exciting graphics, and intuitive interfaces.

    Gambling streams has become an exciting style for players to engage in casino games. Top streamers for example Classy Beef, Roshtein Casino, David Labowsky, Deuce Ace, and Xposed broadcast their casino sessions, often displaying massive jackpots and offering strategies for winning strategies in gambling.

    Furthermore, platforms like BC Game Casino, Bitkingz Casino, and Rocketpot Casino also feature Plinko bets, a fan-favorite game with simple mechanics yet great potential for high payouts.

    Learning about gaming responsibility, refund options, and anonymous play in crypto casinos is necessary for players looking to maximize their gaming experience. Choosing the right wallet, looking for no-registration-required casinos, and learning strategies for games like Aviator Casino Game help players to stay informed while enjoying the thrill of casino gaming.

  229. Тогда, когда выполняется демонтаж с заменой венцов, то деревянный венец также разгружается от напряжения и выполняется демонтаж и монтаж, потому что при замене приподнимание не выше 10 см см, которое не является значительным включая для внутреннего оформления.

    нижние брёвна или брус из лиственных существенно долговечнее и эффективно подтвердил себя благодаря своей надежностью и стойкостью к разложению. Тем не менее, ее точно необходимо защищать через применение антибактериального препарата, наряду с и другие стропила.

    Наше предприятие специализируется не лишь восстановлением зданий, помимо этого обновлением напольных систем. Клиенты нередко запрашивают теплые полы и перекрытия с термической теплоизоляцией наша компания Обеспечиваем заявку всем необходимым для работы и обеспечиваем особые скидки.

  231. volante de equilibrado con cesta de embrague

    Este rotativo de estabilizacion con compartimento de embrague representa un procedimiento fundamental con el proposito de certificar el funcionamiento ideal del propulsor y la transferencia de un camion. El desajuste en la presente pieza tiende a provocar sacudidas, estruendo, uso prematuro de los componentes e incluso fallos. Tradicionalmente, el balanceo se ejecutaba posterior a retirar el girador del motor, sin embargo las desarrollos actuales viabilizan realizar tal proceso sin intermediarios en el automotor, lo que esto reduce plazo y gastos.

    Como se entiende el Desbalance?

    El desbalance representa una situacion en la que la masa de un elemento giratorio (en el actual ejemplo, el volador de nivelacion con recipiente de embrague) se distribuye de modo desigual respecto a su eje de rotacion de movimiento circular. Esta situacion produce esfuerzos centrifugos que generan temblores.

    Principales del Desajuste del Volador de Equilibrado con Compartimento de Embrague:

    Inexactitudes de fabricacion y montaje: Aunque leves desviaciones en la forma de los partes llegan a generar desbalance.
    Envejecimiento y danos: El uso prolongado, el sobrecalentamiento y los fallas mecanicas podrian modificar la cantidad y conducir en desequilibrio.
    Instalacion o reparacion incorrecta: Una instalacion deficiente de la canasto de embrague o arreglos inadecuados igualmente podrian causar falta de equilibrio.

  235. Dicho girador de estabilizacion con recipiente de embrague representa un proceso primordial a fin de asegurar el funcionamiento ideal del motor y la impulsion de un transporte. El desajuste en la presente pieza tiende a causar oscilaciones, estruendo, deterioro rapido de los piezas e llegando a fallas. Anteriormente, el equilibrado se realizaba posterior a sacar el volante del propulsion, no obstante las avances tecnologicos actuales posibilitan realizar tal metodo de forma directa en el vehiculo, lo que esto reduce plazo y costos.

    Cual es el Desbalance?

    El desbalance representa una condicion en la en la que la masa de un pieza giratoria (en el presente ejemplo, el volador de equilibrado con canasto de embrague) se reparte de modo desigual en funcion de su centro de giro de movimiento circular. Esto provoca cargas centrifugas que a su vez causan oscilaciones.

    Causas principales del Desbalance del Girador de Balanceo con Recipiente de Embrague:

    Irregularidades de produccion y union: Aunque leves desviaciones en la estructura de los componentes pueden originar desbalance.
    Deterioro y danos: El operacion prolongada, el exceso de calor y los problemas mecanicos tienden a modificar la masa y provocar en desajuste.
    Colocacion o mantenimiento inapropiada: Una instalacion inadecuada de la canasto de embrague o mantenimientos inapropiados de igual manera llegan a originar desequilibrio.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Enquire Now
Recent Posts