The government has recently initiated a renewed enforcement approach targeting EU citizens holding post-Brexit immigration status, particularly those with pre-settled status under the EU Settlement Scheme. While the measures are grounded in the legal framework established by the 2020 Brexit Withdrawal Agreement, concerns have emerged regarding the methods used to assess individuals’ continued eligibility. Most notably, the reliance on travel data to determine whether applicants have maintained continuous residence in the United Kingdom.

Written by Angel Wan, Solicitor
Legal Framework and Practical Implications
The Home Office has confirmed that it will begin curtailing residency rights for individuals who no longer meet the continuous residence requirements. This development primarily affects the approximately 1.4 million EU citizens who currently hold pre-settled status, granted to those who had not yet completed five years of residence in the UK prior to Brexit.
Under the applicable rules, holders of pre-settled status must not have been absent from the UK for more than a cumulative total of 30 months within any rolling five-year period. By contrast, individuals with settled status benefit from more lenient provisions, allowing absences of up to five consecutive years without losing their rights.
The government has indicated that enforcement efforts will initially focus on individuals believed to have been absent from the UK for extended periods, particularly those exceeding five years. Safeguards are said to be in place, including consideration of reasonable justifications for prolonged absences. The Home Office maintains that these measures are proportionate, lawful, and necessary to preserve the integrity of the immigration system and protect public resources.
However, significant concern has been raised by oversight bodies and advocacy groups regarding the reliability of travel data used in decision-making. Past issues, such as the widely reported HMRC data inaccuracies affecting thousands of benefit claims, have cast doubt on the robustness of Home Office border records. Reported discrepancies include incomplete journey histories, duplicate or conflicting entries, and records of journeys that were booked but never undertaken.
The Independent Monitoring Authority (IMA), responsible for overseeing citizens’ rights agreements, has expressed reservations about how Home Office caseworkers will apply these rules in practice. Similarly, stakeholder organisations have highlighted the risk of erroneous decisions being made on the basis of flawed data, potentially leading to unjust status revocations.
Conclusion
The increasing reliance on automated or semi-automated data in immigration decision-making raises important questions regarding procedural fairness, evidential standards, and individuals’ ability to challenge adverse outcomes. Errors in such data may carry significant consequences, including the loss of lawful status and associated rights to work, rent, and access services in the UK.
The UK’s intensified approach to monitoring compliance with post-Brexit residency requirements marks a significant shift in the administration of the EU Settlement Scheme. While the legal basis for enforcement is clear, the practical implementation, particularly the reliance on potentially unreliable travel data, poses notable risks for affected individuals.
Therefore, it is crucial for EU citizens holding pre-settled status to proactively monitor their residence records, retain independent evidence of their physical presence in the UK, and seek legal advice where concerns arise. As enforcement measures evolve, ensuring procedural fairness and safeguarding individuals’ rights will remain central to maintaining confidence in the UK’s post-Brexit immigration system.
Have questions? Get in touch today!
Call our office on 020 7928 0276, we will be taking calls from 9:30am to 6:00pm.
Email us on [email protected].
Or, use the contact form on our website. Simply enter your details and leave a message, we will get right back to you: https://lisaslaw.co.uk/contact/
For more updates, follow us on our social media platforms! You can find them all on our Linktree right here.




